The healthcare landscape in rural America continues to face significant challenges including worsening physician shortages, accelerating hospital closures, and persistent geographic barriers to care. Telehealth technologies—the remote delivery of healthcare services through telecommunications infrastructure—have demonstrated measurable success in addressing these disparities over the past several years. This white paper examines the current state of telehealth technologies in 2012, evidence-based outcomes from initial implementation efforts, remaining barriers to widespread adoption, and policy recommendations to expand telehealth’s reach across rural America.

Introduction

Rural communities in the United States face substantial healthcare access challenges that have intensified in recent years. Approximately 20% of Americans live in rural areas, yet these regions are home to less than 9% of physicians, a disparity that continues to grow. The problem is compounded by the accelerating closure of rural hospitals, with over 40 facilities having closed between 2007-2012 alone. These communities consistently experience poorer health outcomes compared to their urban counterparts, with higher rates of chronic disease, disability, and mortality.

Telehealth—the use of electronic information and telecommunications technologies to support clinical healthcare, patient and professional health-related education, and public health administration from a distance—has moved from theoretical promise to practical solution over the past five years. With broadband infrastructure expansion and decreasing technology costs, telehealth implementations now demonstrate measurable improvements in care access, quality, and cost-effectiveness for rural populations.

Current State of Telehealth Technologies in 2012

Telehealth technologies have evolved considerably over the last decade, with several categories now showing robust implementation:

1. Store-and-Forward Technologies: These asynchronous applications have become standard practice in specialties like radiology and pathology, with growing adoption in dermatology, ophthalmology, and wound care. Image quality improvements and declining costs have accelerated adoption rates.

2. Remote Patient Monitoring (RPM): This sector has experienced significant growth, particularly in chronic disease management. Cardiac monitoring leads implementation, with over 200,000 patients now utilizing home-based cardiac monitoring systems nationwide. Diabetes management programs have also demonstrated positive outcomes through remote glucose monitoring and telehealth coaching.

3. Real-time Interactive Services: Video consultation platforms have matured considerably, with between 500,000 and 800,000 estimated consultations conducted in 2011 nationwide. High-definition video capabilities, simplified user interfaces, and enhanced security features have improved both clinical utility and user experience.

The number of active telehealth networks has more than doubled since 2007, with approximately 450 programs now operating nationwide. The Veterans Health Administration’s telehealth program stands as the largest implementation, serving over 50,000 veterans annually, many in rural locations.

Evidence-Based Benefits for Rural Healthcare

The past five years have produced substantial evidence supporting telehealth’s effectiveness in rural settings:

Improved Access to Specialists

Multiple studies now document telehealth’s capacity to extend specialty care to rural communities:
• A 2011 study of rural telepsychiatry implementations found that psychiatric admissions decreased by an average of 24.2%, and days of hospitalization decreased by an average of 26.6%
• The STROKE-DOC program demonstrated since launching in 2007 has shown significant project including A 2009 study published in Stroke showed telestroke consultation increased tPA use from 5% to 24% in rural hospitals

Demonstrated Cost Savings

Economic analyses now provide concrete evidence of telehealth’s cost-effectiveness:
• Remote monitoring of heart failure patients reduced 30-day hospital readmissions by 38% in a 2011 multi-center study, generating net savings of $1,450 per patient
• The average cost of a telehealth visit in established programs ranges from $40-50, compared to $136-176 for comparable in-person encounters
• Rural hospitals implementing telehealth services report reduced patient transfer costs averaging $5,600 per avoided transfer

Measurable Quality Improvements

Quality metrics demonstrate telehealth’s clinical effectiveness:
• Telehealth-supported diabetes management programs show average HbA1c reductions of 1.2-1.8% compared to usual care
• Rural ICUs with tele-ICU support experienced 15-30% reductions in mortality rates and decreased lengths of stay by 2.1 days
• Patient satisfaction scores for telehealth consultations now frequently match or exceed in-person care (4.5/5 vs. 4.3/5 in a 2012 cross-sectional analysis)

Provider Workforce Benefits

Telehealth positively impacts rural provider recruitment and retention:
• Rural hospitals with telehealth support report 17% higher physician satisfaction rates
• Night and weekend coverage through telehealth has reduced on-call burden by up to 30% for rural providers
• 73% of rural facilities using telehealth report improved recruitment outcomes when telehealth is included in practice descriptions

Implementation Progress and Remaining Challenges

While telehealth adoption has accelerated significantly, implementation barriers persist:
Technical Infrastructure
Broadband availability has improved but remains inadequate in many rural areas:
• Rural broadband penetration increased from 38% in 2007 to 57% in 2012
• However, 26% of rural communities still lack access to the 4 Mbps download speeds recommended for high-quality video consultation
• Mobile broadband expansion presents new opportunities, with 67% of rural counties now having at least partial 3G coverage

Financial Sustainability

Reimbursement has improved but remains inconsistent:
• Medicare now reimburses for telehealth services in designated Health Professional Shortage Areas, though restrictions on eligible originating sites and covered services remain
• 14 states have enacted “parity laws” requiring private insurers to cover telehealth services
• The significant upfront costs for equipment acquisition and implementation ($15,000-50,000 for basic systems) remain barriers for financially stressed rural providers

Regulatory Environment

Progress has been made on regulatory issues:
• Seven states have joined the Nurse Licensure Compact, facilitating interstate nursing practice
• The Federation of State Medical Boards is developing an interstate physician licensing compact
• The HITECH Act has established clearer security and privacy guidelines for telehealth implementations
• However, variation in state regulations creates continued complexity for multi-state operations

Clinical Integration and Workforce Development

New implementation challenges have emerged:
• Effective integration with electronic health records remains challenging, with only 30% of telehealth systems offering seamless EHR integration
• Provider training and workflow redesign represent significant implementation barriers
• Clinical protocols and best practices for telehealth are still evolving in many specialties

Emerging Applications and Opportunities

Several promising applications are now moving from pilot phase to broader implementation:

School-Based Telehealth

• Over 350 school-based telehealth programs now operate nationwide
• These programs demonstrate 63% reductions in school absences and 85% reductions in emergency department visits for participating students
• Particularly valuable for managing chronic conditions like asthma in rural settings

Emergency Department Support

• Tele-emergency services now connect rural emergency departments with board-certified emergency physicians and specialists
• Early implementations show 35% reductions in unnecessary transfers and improved adherence to evidence-based protocols
• Critical for rural facilities facing nighttime and weekend coverage challenges

Behavioral Health Integration

• Collaborative care models using telehealth to integrate behavioral health into primary care settings
• Particularly valuable in addressing rural mental health provider shortages
• Early outcomes show 25% improvements in depression scores and 30% reductions in psychiatric hospitalizations

Home-Based Chronic Care Management

• Remote monitoring combined with telehealth coaching shows particular promise for rural elderly populations
• Reduces barriers related to transportation and mobility limitations
• Initial programs demonstrate 27% reductions in overall healthcare utilization

Policy Recommendations

To accelerate telehealth adoption and maximize its impact on rural healthcare, we recommend the following policy initiatives:

Reform Reimbursement Structures

• Eliminate Medicare’s originating site restrictions for rural telehealth services
• Expand the definition of covered telehealth services to include remote patient monitoring and store-and-forward applications
• Incentivize commercial insurers to adopt telehealth parity through demonstration projects and tax incentives

Strengthen Rural Connectivity

• Increase funding for the FCC’s Rural Health Care Program to support broadband infrastructure development
• Target the Universal Service Fund to prioritize healthcare connectivity in unserved rural areas
• Create tax incentives for telecommunications companies developing rural broadband infrastructure

Harmonize Regulatory Frameworks

• Support the development and adoption of interstate licensure compacts for all healthcare professions
• Standardize credentialing and privileging requirements for telehealth providers
• Develop consistent practice guidelines and standards across jurisdictions

Invest in Implementation Support

• Expand the Office for the Advancement of Telehealth’s grant programs for rural telehealth implementation
• Develop technical assistance resources specifically targeting small rural providers
• Create workforce development programs focused on telehealth competencies

Conclusion and Future Outlook

Telehealth has transitioned from an experimental approach to an evidence-based strategy for addressing rural healthcare disparities. The demonstrated benefits in access, quality, and cost-effectiveness establish telehealth as an essential component of rural healthcare delivery systems.

Looking ahead to 2015-2020, we anticipate:
• Integration of telehealth into accountable care organizations and patient-centered medical homes
• Enhanced capabilities through higher-bandwidth applications, improved mobile technologies, and advanced sensors
• Development of artificial intelligence applications to support clinical decision-making
• Expansion beyond traditional healthcare settings into homes, schools, workplaces, and mobile units
With appropriate policy support and continued technological innovation, telehealth is positioned to fundamentally transform rural healthcare delivery. By building on the substantial progress of the past five years and addressing remaining implementation barriers, we can create a healthcare system where geography no longer determines access to high-quality care.

________________________________________

About the Author
This white paper was prepared by a technology expert with extensive experience in healthcare technology solutions and an understanding of telehealth solutions in rural healthcare systems. The analysis draws on current research, implementation case studies, and outcome data as of April 2012.